Version 2 2025-06-30, 05:58Version 2 2025-06-30, 05:58
Version 1 2025-06-25, 04:33Version 1 2025-06-25, 04:33
journal contribution
posted on 2025-06-30, 05:58authored byAllison Mills
In March 2016, J. K. Rowling launched four new short stories entitled The History of Magic in North America. It is safe to say that Rowling did not anticipate the reactions from Indigenous critics that these stories incited. In what was probably a well-intentioned attempt at inclusivity, Rowling's stories reference "the Native American community" ("Fourteenth Century") and their place in the world of Harry Potter. In doing so, she stepped on a land mine. Magic in North America's treatment of North American Indigenous communities is, at best, misguided, and at worst stereotypical and appropriative.
Although Indigenous fans, critics and their allies spent much of the month following the release of these stories tweeting Rowling, as of this article going to press in July 2016, she has yet to respond in detail to the criticism she has faced, and the articles are still available at Pottermore. Although Rowling is certainly not the first white author to misstep in her treatment of I...
History
Journal
The Looking Glass : New Perspectives on Children's Literature
ISSN
1551-5680
Volume
19
Issue
1
Publisher
La Trobe University
Section Title
Jabberwocky
Author Biography
Allison Mills is an MAS/MLIS candidate at the University of British Columbia, where she also obtained an MFA in Creative Writing with a focus on writing for children. Her research interests include the portrayal of First Nations and Indigenous peoples in children's literature and the care of Indigenous knowledge in libraries and archives. She is of mixed Mushkegowuk Cree and French-Canadian ancestry.
Date Created
2016-07-25
Rights Statement
Essays and articles published in The Looking Glass may be reproduced for non-profit use by any educational or public institution; letters to the editor and on-site comments made by our readers may not be used without the expressed permission of that individual. Any commercial use of this journal, in whole or in part, by any means, is prohibited. Authors of accepted articles assign to The Looking Glass the right to publish and distribute their text electronically and to archive and make it permanently available electronically. They retain the copyright and, 90 days after initial publication, may republish it in any form they wish as long as The Looking Glass is acknowledged as the original source.
Data source
OJS data migration 2025: https://ojs.latrobe.edu.au/ojs/index.php/tlg/article/view/764