La Trobe

File(s) under permanent embargo

Reason: Under copyright

Remorse: Multi-disciplinary Perspectives on How Law Makes Use of a Moral Emotion

chapter
posted on 27.07.2021, 23:28 by Steven TudorSteven Tudor, Michael Proeve, Richard Weisman, Kate Rossmanith
This chapter examines, from multiple disciplinary perspectives, a variety of issues raised when the remorseful (or unremorseful) offender comes before the law. It first looks at how remorse is defined, how it differs from shame and guilt, and whether the law should define remorse more precisely. It then turns to the question of how remorse is attributed in legal contexts, looking at what counts as evidence of remorse (including courtroom demeanour) and whether doubts about reliable findings of remorse at the sentencing stage mean the task should be left to parole hearings or even abandoned altogether. The chapter then looks at how the law is to acknowledge proven offender remorse (for example, through mitigation of punishment), and whether unremorseful offenders should be punished more severely than remorseful offenders. Finally, the chapter examines how the law helps to create and maintain moral communities through how it deals with remorse, including through its expectations of remorse and its power to decide when a showing of remorse is credible. The importance of this role is particularly evident in transitional societies, in which one moral community is undone and replaced by another.

History

Publication Date

27/04/2021

Book Title

Research Handbook on Law and Emotion

Editors

Bandes SA Madeira JL Temple KD Kidd White E

Publisher

Edward Elgar Publishing

Place of publication

United Kingdom

Series

Research Handbooks in Legal Theory

Pagination

15p. (p. 131-145)

ISBN-13

9781788119078

Rights Statement

The Author reserves all moral rights over the deposited text and must be credited if any re-use occurs. Documents deposited in OPAL are the Open Access versions of outputs published elsewhere. Changes resulting from the publishing process may therefore not be reflected in this document. The final published version may be obtained via the publisher’s DOI. Please note that additional copyright and access restrictions may apply to the published version.

Usage metrics

Categories

Exports